Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Charisma & The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo





She is a loner. Aloof at all times, and surly to everybody, she downplays her looks by wearing black make-up and rocking a variety of piercings. The large dragon tattoo on her back is grotesque, appearing to literally be bursting free from her body. None of it is appealing to anyone but the most die hard goth/emo puke. Most normal people on the street who have more than a passing encounter with her find her repellant. Yet after you see this girl in action, getting a glimpse into her private life, you find her fascinating and you cannot look away. Inner beauty reveals itself in the form of steel-trap intelligence, physical pound for pound power, and certain invincibility.

Lisbeth is the titular character in the amazing Swedish crime thriller The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. In the film, this young woman, who already comes to us with half a dozen lifetimes of bad baggage, gets involved in one horrifying situation of another, whether in her own private life or in that of the famous journalist she is “cyberstalking” for the high end private investigation firm she freelances for. In a business monotone Lisbeth talks to a room of suit and tie professionals; fully out of place and almost bizarre in her macabre fashion statements. But the men in the room know her work, and have nothing but respect for her amazing computer research talents. These older, experienced private investigators look to her for the deep information that they cannot dig up on the streets. Lisbeth can find out anything about anybody.

Out in the urban jungle, Lisbeth is swift and canny, escaping one deadly situation after another, whether it be drunk punks in the metro looking to humiliate her for her appearance, brutal state imposed mentors who look to abuse her for sick pleasure, or even serial killers, Lisbeth comes out of each and every situation she enters on top. In the rare times she does not, she survives to return to exact brutal vengeance on any man who looks to harm her or the few people she is loyal too.

This weekend I saw the sequel to that great movie, The Girl Who Played with Fire, at an Academy of Science Fiction screening in West LA. Almost as great as the first, it got even deeper into the character of Lisbeth and her private world of violence and vengeance.

And it had me thinking about Charisma, in game terms, like it did when I watched the first film in the trilogy. This repellant and generally unattractive girl, so unlikeable on first meeting, actually turns out to have an almost irresistible, edgy charm. You only have to get a glimpse of her life to find yourself rooting for her in all of her misadventures. Those who see the true Lisbeth see an amazing and powerful charisma.

There are so many examples of repugnant individuals real and imagined who have big charisma, from Hitler to Hannibal Lector, who somehow have a strange magnetism. So many factors are involved. I think we have all hated somebody not knowing them at all, but after some acquaintance we change our minds completely about them.

Out of all statistics in a game like, say, D&D, I think charisma is the most difficult to apply in any kind of realistic manner. Even the somewhat abstract concept of Wisdom is easier to figure out in a real life way. In D&D, charisma helps you with how many henchfolk you can have, and give you a base reaction in encounters where it is appropriate. But let’s face it, that is more of a cartoony “winning smile” charisma. Tony Curtis in The Great Race flashing those white, gleaming choppers so charismatically that thrown pies won’t even dare sully him.

But how to make charisma more like it is in the real world? I’m guessing for a game like D&D it is just too much trouble. You’d have to take in both the persons speaking manner, their body language, looks, and actions. Plus you would have to look at any number of factors involved in the person we need a charisma related action from.

What can you do? I guess we’ll just have to keep charisma simple until a renowned gamer psychologist comes forward to put a better spin on it. Any out there?

10 comments:

  1. Cool! Those movies and the novels are so huge here in Scandinavia. I was surprised to see that picture in a gaming blog, but that is cool :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Havard: Thanks, bro. I have to tell you, if somebody told me a year ago that the two best movies I've seen this year are from Europe, and in subtitles no less, I'd have had them locked up in Arkham Asylum. I need to look more into the cinema of that part of the planet. Just great damn stuff. I hope the upcoming American remake (with Daniel Craig, I think) doesn't totally blow chunks. I'm sure it won't be half as edgy and thrilling.

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you look at CHA as a person's ability to enact his will on others in soem fashion, then I think it works okay. It's up to you to define how it works. Are you charming or creepily magnetic? Both work as high CHA.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I saw Men Who Hate Women on Sunday.
    --I was very much impressed, but equally disdainful of what the Hollywood version would end up like.

    ReplyDelete
  5. great movies and a great character indeed!

    if you like movies but dislike/ignore european ones...

    you are doing it wrong. ;)

    there's going to be a remake? with daniel craig?! *shudders* i wonder which hollywood blondie will give lisbeth a totally different kind of "charisma". :D

    ps: there is a third part as well, just in case you didn't know.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1343097/

    But how to make charisma more like it is in the real world? I’m guessing for a game like D&D it is just too much trouble.

    if at all possible.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Matt: I doubt that is what Gygax and company had in mind, but like so many things in the game it is up to us to tweak things like charisma. The last time I thought about this was the main character in Sexy Beast - a guy who gets what he wants through sheer intimidation. Charisma?
    TimeShad: I know that is the name of the original book. In Europe did they go with those titles as well, and these other names were given to the American releases?

    ReplyDelete
  7. * The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo (original Swedish title Män Som Hatar Kvinnor, literally Men Who Hate Women)
    * The Girl Who Played with Fire (original Swedish title Flickan Som Lekte Med Elden, literally The Girl Who Played With The Fire)
    * The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets' Nest (original Swedish title Luftslottet Som Sprängdes, literally The Air Castle That Exploded)

    the german titles were:
    verblendung, verdammnis and vergebung.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Shlo: Thanks man. Now since you are in the know, do you happen to know if any of the books have been released in English? I'd love to read the 3rd book before I see the film.

    ReplyDelete
  9. i don't really know much about the books, but wikipedia does. :)

    The third novel in the Millennium trilogy, published in English as The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets' Nest, was published in the United States in May 2010.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I've heard about these books, but I have yet to hear about them in a way I find appealing. Yet I keep hearing about them... maybe I will have to check them out. Any yes, charisma means a lot of things. I once ran a D&D wizard with a higher CHA than INT and I thought it would be fun to run a wizard kind of like Bluto from Animal House. My DM at the time hated the idea. So, the character died. So CHA means what the DM says it means.

    ReplyDelete